LJ Cunningham

Identity Christians and the Republican Party

Identity Christians are anti-Semitic, anti-Catholic, anti-Black, Republican Party darlings who believe in the racial purity of the Aryan race.

Post Published: May 1, 2023

Identity Christians have been pushing their agenda, and embedding their framework, into the Republican Party, and party-sponsored legislation for longer than you may think. 

The  Southern Poverty Law Center websites provide information on Identity Christians, both sources claiming the movement has lost members since the 1980s.

I disagree.

Identity Christians & White Supremacy

Identity Christians are anti-Semitic, anti-Catholic, anti-Black Republican Party darlings who promote the racial purity of the Aryan race.

In the 1920s and 30s, E.P. Ingersoll and Howard Rand merged British Israeli antisemitism from Europe with American Protestantism. They propagated the belief that peoples from Germanic, “Aryan” nations are the true Israelis. This and other anti-Semitic ideology was easily translated in families and churches.

Because Christian Identity is not a specific church, its tenants can be fluid, and adaptable to the times. There are specific churches, however, tied to the Aryan Nation and other neo-Nazi groups both inside and outside of prisons.

“Lower races,” according to Identity Christians, are not in God’s favor. Only those who are “ruddy” (can turn red in the sun) are God’s servants; and only those from Nordic/Germanic Europe.

James Aho wrote “The penalties for race-mixing, homo-sexuality, and usury are death,”  in 1990’s The politics of righteousness : Idaho Christian patriotism

Examples of Christian Identity Ideology in Plain Sight

A simple Google Search of “Pure Blood Republicans” turns up a plethora of merch for people proudly Republican, American, and/or refusing the COVID-19 vaccine.

When Mary Miller, Illinois Republican and Trump supporter, called Roe v Wade’s overturning “a historic victory for white life,” it made perfect sense within the Christian Identity framework. While it is easy and more comfortable to see stories in newsfeeds and timelines and assume something akin to “delusions” or other ableist language, I have a different suggestion.

Consider that the most restrictive legislation in the country comes directly from people who:
1. Believe their whiteness makes them God’s chosen people
2. Consider “race-mixing” and queerness akin to beastiality
3. Do not trust science, medicine, or state-funded education
4. Believe that any escalation in public discord encourages their belief in living in the End Times
5. That they are correct, and everyone else is not

A terrific example of this comes straight from Ohio. Republican State Representative Sarah Fowler-Arthur made statements sympathizing with “German soldiers” during WWII. The concerning comments came during a live interview with Morgan Trau in defense of refusing “CRT” being taught in K-12 public schools.

Fowler-Arthur, herself a homeschool graduate from a rural Ohio county, has built her political career attempting to take SEL out of schools and criticizing sex education. She recently attempted a bill allowing people who without social work education to perform social worker duties in Ohio.

Like the Moms of Liberty today making the rounds on social media, this ideology isn’t new: it’s just different now because of tech.


Online spaces are rife with imagery and ideology just like that listed above; and with younger people. The last President gave voice to the self-identifying victims who voted for him. The cult mentality seen in MAGA and Right Wing circles makes sense in this framework. It existed long before he was President.

What if  we are collectively watching a much more radicalized group than we’d initially understood? One with larger goals than religion and politics?

Is it possible that this is no accident, and actually a cohesive effort?

Are we ready to collectively have difficult discourse about how white Christianity is intertwined with white supremacy?

Can we afford not to?



Share Your Thoughts Below:

Recent Posts
Collage of Ohio representatives from top left, Bill Dean, Melanie Miller, Jennifer Gross who is standing beside Kyle Rittenhouse; and Beth Lear who is aiming a gun

How Should the People Respond to the Undemocratic Ohio GOP?

Ohio Republicans Bill Dean, Melanie Miller, Beth Lear, and Jennifer...

a row of empty church pews

Pastors Push Politics at Ohio Pulpit

Share via: More I’d posted online to speak to Ohio...

A protester's hands are visible holding a sign that reads they are coming for your rights next. The ohio statehouse with the ohio and american flag are in the background

Vote For Issue 1 To Protect Reproductive Rights In Ohio

Everything to Know About the Vote to Pass Issue 1...

Mount Olive Baptist Church, church and cemetery of the late Reverend Jacob Cossart, my seventh great-grandfather, and father of Mary Cozad, grandfather of Charity Hinesman.

White Supremacy Lies I Used To Believe

I wrote about being raised to be a Christian Nationalist...

Image shows two girls standing facing one another. One with blonde braids and one with darker hair in the same style. They appear to stand in a woods, wearing older fashioned, feminine clothing. The blonde girl is covered neck to wrist wearing a dress. The darker haired girl faces her wearing more modern black clothing. They face one another and seen in profile

Racism as a Legacy Burden

My therapist introduced me to the concept of legacy burdens....

Share via
Copy link